After Mkhize slams Prof Gray, she says she criticised the regulations, not the lockdown


After Mkhize slams Prof Gray, she says she criticised the regulations, not the lockdown

Professor Glenda Gray (Photo by Gallo Images / Foto24 /Bongiwe Gumede)

Professor Glenda Gray has informed Information24 that she feels she is being singled out, saying it’s ‘worrying’ after Health Minister Zweli Mkhize slammed her criticism of presidency’s Covid-19 lockdown technique and laws.

Mkhize stated her statements have been “devoid in reality”.

Gray is a member of the Ministerial Advisory Committee (MAC) and chairperson of the South African Medical Research Council (SAMRC). She is an skilled in infectious ailments, HIV and has coaching in paediatrics.

In an announcement on Wednesday evening, Mkhize stated he had learn the article by Information24, which additionally included remark from three different MAC members.

Mkhize stated he was “bowled over by the apparent inaccuracies it incorporates which have, in my opinion, induced pointless sensationalism and doubt on the work and energy of the authorities in coping with Covid-19”.

Mkhize referenced 5 feedback made by Gray, which he stated have been “factually incorrect” – these regarding malnutrition circumstances in kids at Chris Hani Baragwanath Hospital, the de-escalation of the lockdown, recommendation given by the MAC, sure laws surrounding the lockdown and holding kids out of college.

Gray beforehand questioned why authorities determined not to take the recommendation of the MAC or “interact readily” with the specialists.

However, Mkhize stated since its institution, the MAC had submitted 50 advisories, “all of which have been accepted”.

“Throughout this era, the NCCC (National Coronavirus Command Council) has welcomed these displays. In truth, the President has constantly acknowledged and counseled the scientific information made obtainable by the Department of Health via the MAC,” Mkhize stated.

“I’ve seen it match to provide this detailed background with a view to spotlight that at no level has the Department of Health or Government as a complete ignored and not responded to the recommendation of the Ministerial Advisory Committee on Covid-19,” he added.

Gray beforehand informed Information24 that Chris Hani Baragwanath Hospital in Soweto noticed a rise in acute malnutrition circumstances in kids in the first week of May, which she stated wanted shut monitoring.

Mkhize, nevertheless, stated there had been a discount in circumstances of malnutrition at the hospital for March and April in comparison with the earlier 4 years.

“I’ve been suggested by the Department’s officers that at a subsequent Covid-19 MAC assembly, Prof Velaphi, the Head of Paediatrics at the hospital, raised this concern and requested why Prof Gray would mislead the public by giving inaccurate info.

“Prof Gray merely said that she had relied on what she had heard from ‘different colleagues’.

“However, these colleagues have been not disclosed,” Mkhize stated.

Speaking to Information24, Gray stated: “I want to be fallacious about this.

“Every admission for malnutrition is a tragedy; the will increase in the first week of May is hopefully an unrelated aberration and it does not proceed,” she added.

Gray beforehand maintained that the lockdown technique “is not based mostly on science and is totally unmeasured”, including “[i]t’s virtually as if somebody is sucking laws out of their thumb and implementing garbage”.

She reiterated on Wednesday evening that she did not criticise the lockdown or the extension of the lockdown, including that it was in actual fact important, however emphasised that her feedback associated to laws.

“I spoke in my private capability. The phrases of reference of the MAC clearly states one is on the MAC of their private capability. As I’ve repeatedly said, I did not criticise the lockdown,” Gray emphasised.

In his assertion, Mkhize defined that buildings inside authorities took into consideration scientific and socioeconomic elements.

“The remark that authorities thumb-sucks its resolution not solely undermines the joint work and energy that the NCCC, Cabinet and authorities as a complete has been engaged in however it’s also unprofessional and unbecoming conduct from a member of the MAC who has direct entry to the Ministry and the Department.

“In my view, it undermines and brings into disrepute the establishment that Prof Gray works for, which is an entity of the Department of Health, the MRC (SAMRC),” Mkhize stated.

He stated that, “satirically”, Gray had been making ready an advisory to the minister of well being referring to the lockdown, nevertheless it had not been submitted to the minister when Gray spoke to the media.

Gray stated she believed that many different scientists had been vocal on the challenge and probably extra “vociferous”.

“Being singled out is worrying,” she stated.

Mkhize stated: “Divergent views by scientists are wholesome and welcome. The MAC gives this platform for strong engagement of those high scientists who’re leaders of varied respectable establishments and organisations.

“However, I need to urge all those that are contributing to the thought course of and science behind the selections finally undertaken by Government to desist from probably harmful behaviour and proceed to have interaction constructively with Government as they’re mandated.

“We might not at all times agree however we are going to pay attention and think about enter dropped at us. We have stated that authorities will not combat this pandemic alone.”

For extra information your method, Orignaly Published on  and 

live at 2020-05-21 09:44:12



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here