Ramaphosa threatened with possible litigation over constitutionality of Covid-19 council


Ramaphosa threatened with possible litigation over constitutionality of Covid-19 council

President Cyril Ramaphosa.

‘The NCC [National Command Council] seems to us to represent a centralisation of energy that’s impermissible below the Disaster Management Act,’ the letter reads.

Two of the nation’s high-profile advocates have written a authorized letter to President Cyril Ramaphosa to request readability on the powers wielded by the National Command Council (NCC) in cost of the response to the novel coronavirus.

In a nine-page letter by means of RHK Attorneys, advocates Nazeer Cassim and Erin Dianne Richards say they’re involved concerning the possible dangers of constitutional and democratic malfunctioning.

This, they are saying, arises from what seems to be the questionable institution, construction and features of the NCC, in addition to the noticeable lack of transparency from the federal government concerning the physique.

“The drawback is that the NCC solely consists of 19 ministers. That isn’t all the nationwide govt. Where are the remaining ministers? On its present composition, the NCC seems to us to represent a centralisation of energy that’s impermissible below the Disaster Management Act,” the letter reads.

The two have threatened to take the matter to their moral our bodies for possible litigation, if the president fails to reply.

The advocates say that, from the data obtainable to them, the NCC seems to be displacing constitutional and statutory functionaries below the Disaster Management Act (DMA). This is compromising parliamentary oversight, opening the door to potential unchecked abuses or excesses of State energy.

The two advocates query the data disseminated by the media, declaring that statements made by ministers are, at occasions, contradictory.

This concern was shared by the DA earlier this month, when it referred to as for National Assembly Speaker Thandi Modise to arrange an oversight committee over the manager through the lockdown. The request was rejected by Modise.

“Perhaps most unsettling is the influence that an illegal train of govt energy by the NCC would have on parliamentary oversight: shifting govt energy from your self and 28 ministers to your self and 19 ministers throws the parliamentary oversight mechanisms into full chaos as a result of it interrupts the odd functioning of portfolios and their committees.

“It accordingly seems that the NCC is exercising no less than two kinds of energy: the primary of these being statutory regulation-making powers and the second of these being govt powers of coordination and administration of the catastrophe. We see no lawful foundation for the NCC to intrude within the making of rules, nor will we see any lawful foundation for the physique to train every other statutory regulation-making powers below the DMA,” the letter reads.

They argue that solely Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs Nkosazana Dlamini-Zuma has the powers to difficulty rules after session with the related cupboard member, including that no different physique has any authority to find out rules, intrude within the course of of the dedication of rules, or revise rules.

“If there may be substance to the priority about regulatory interference, it’s our opinion that this may immediately impugn the lawfulness of the rules to which all the nation is at present being subjected. It is, subsequently, of the utmost significance that clarification be offered.”

Speaking to Information24, Cassim stated the letter was a pleasant clarity-seeking request to the president. He added that, whereas he understood the burden of Ramaphosa’s workplace, it doesn’t detract from the requirement that every one workout routines of energy have to be lawful.

“You ought to keep away from a scenario the place you’ve gotten absolute energy and absolute management. The equipment have to be guided by the Constitution. You can’t discard the judiciary and parliament. You can’t have an govt appointing whomever, as they’re doing now, within the nation. The conduct of the federal government must not ever be unchecked,” he stated.

For extra information your manner, Orignaly Published on https://citizen.co.za  and 

live at 2020-04-29 18:24:08



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here